Authors: Standage, Martyn¹; Treasure, Darren C.²; Hooper, Katherine¹; Kuczka, Kendy²

Source: British Journal of Educational Psychology, Volume 77, Number 1, March 2007 , pp. 81-99(19)

Abstract:

BackgroundSelf-handicapping is an attribution-related process whereby individuals create performance impediments/excuses to protect self-worth in socially evaluative environments. Thus, the prevailing motivational climate would appear to be an important factor when attempting to understand the situational self-handicapping process within school physical education.

AimsDrawing from achievement goal theory, the study examined the effect of experimentally induced conditions (viz. task vs. ego) on situational self-handicapping.

SampleSeventy British secondary school students (36 females and 34 males; M age = 11.98; SD=0.31).

MethodParticipants were randomly assigned to partake in a running endurance task in either an ego-involving (20 male students and 16 female students) or a task-involving (14 male students and 20 female students) condition. Prior to completing the experimental task, participants were given the opportunity to claim situational self-handicaps. Data for goal orientations, subjective climate perceptions, perceived ability and perceived task importance were also obtained.

ResultsAfter determining the effectiveness of the experimental manipulation, results revealed participants in the ego-involving condition to report significantly more situational self-handicapping claims. Further, and after controlling for individual difference variables, the results of moderated hierarchical regression analysis revealed subjective perceptions of an ego-involving climate to be the main positive predictor of situational self-handicapping. Although a weaker contributor to the percentage of variance explained, task orientation emerged as a negative predictor of situational self-handicapping.

ConclusionsThe findings suggest that PE teachers would be prudent to minimize ego-involving situations should they wish to reduce situational self-handicapping.

Document Type: Research article

DOI: 10.1348/000709906X103636

Affiliations: 1: University of Bath, UK 2: Arizona State University, USA